ITAOTS survivor round 2 and 1/2

[Zop]

It seems like having a choice of every song on the album makes it impossible for any one song to compete with comm daughter, so I cut down the choices. Sorry if I omitted anyone's favorite song!

[clouds-chan]

Well this is lovely.

[Zop]

My sarcasm meter is broken so either you're welcome or I'm sorry.

[Stormx]

...I still don't understand. Do we vote for our favourite or least favourite song? This idea stinks >.<

[cloud-chan]

Favorite song, I'm pretty sure. Though the thread-creators should be more specific.

[furious-chan]

AAAAAHHHHHHHHGGGGG I HATE COMMUNIST DAUGHTER.

[Zop]

Originally posted by Stormx
...I still don't understand. Do we vote for our favourite or least favourite song? This idea stinks >.<

I don't understand your misunderstanding. It's for favorite song...I think. Is that ok?

EDIT: The premise is that by only voting on the choices that had the most votes in round 1, the other songs won't take away votes from songs that actually have a chance to win.

[Edited on 8-27-0606 by Zop]

[idrankhemlock]

Originally posted by furious-chan
AAAAAHHHHHHHHGGGGG I HATE COMMUNIST DAUGHTER. how the hell can you hate one of the better songs on the album?

[furious-chan]

Originally posted by idrankhemlock
Originally posted by furious-chan
AAAAAHHHHHHHHGGGGG I HATE COMMUNIST DAUGHTER. how the hell can you hate one of the better songs on the album?

Because my name is "furious-chan" and so I have to be furious about something.

[Stormx]

Well my favourite song has been taken away now anyway >.<

[idrankhemlock]

Originally posted by furious-chan
Originally posted by idrankhemlock
Originally posted by furious-chan
AAAAAHHHHHHHHGGGGG I HATE COMMUNIST DAUGHTER. how the hell can you hate one of the better songs on the album?

Because my name is "furious-chan" and so I have to be furious about something.
w3rd

[clouds-chan]

I keep confusing cloud-chan with me.

[tomatoesandradiowires]

I can't imagine why. you're the one that makes teh sweet music. ( i just checked your myspace out.)

[Loial]

I don't get it. Comm daughter is my least favorite track on the album. Even the instrumentals are better.

[clouds-chan]

Originally posted by tomatoesandradiowires
I can't imagine why. you're the one that makes teh sweet music. ( i just checked your myspace out.)

aha, thanks, i reposted the link to the album, if you didn't notice, hehe

[FourteenElephants]

Originally posted by Loial
I don't get it. Comm daughter is my least favorite track on the album. Even the instrumentals are better.

Apparently very few people agree with you?

[Stormx]

I agree... totally...

[atrocities]

Originally posted by Stormx
Well my favourite song has been taken away now anyway >.<

[tomatoesandradiowires]

Apparently Communist daughter is just one of those songs you either love or you hate.


Or sort of like. or are indifferent to, or are close to loving except for that one part about semen staining mountaintops etc.

[clouds-chan]

it's one of those songs you love or hate at varying levels, depending on the person's likes and dislikes and tastes and distastes.

[Zop]

Well it's the kind of song that's either a song or not a song. In this case, it's a song. Or not.

Should we do this again with 3 choices or just declare communist daughter the winner?

[Edited on 8-28-0606 by Zop]

[clouds-chan]

I think we know it won.

[Zop]

Yeah.

[Stormx]

I think we knew that before anyone voted on the first one :P

[tomatoesandradiowires]

wait, people have voted for communist daughter? I hadn't noticed.

[Mutineer]

Haha, am I the only one who thinks "Communist Daughter" was just meant for filler?

[Stormx]

Same.... I swear someone has registered like a million user accounts and voted for communist daughter every time. I *really* don't like it.

[idrankhemlock]

Originally posted by Mutineer
Haha, am I the only one who thinks "Communist Daughter" was just meant for filler?
i would hope so

[Mutineer]

"Oh Sister" > "Communist Daughter"

Srsly.

[Aqualad]

You spelled Awesomeville wrong, I think.

[carrotus_rex]

I vote for the White Album.

[tomatoesandradiowires]

I didn't spell it wrong; those that created the town did. I don't have the gall to challenge my forefathers.

[Aqualad]

I don't blame you, it's hard for me to take on the one father I have, let alone forefathers.

[Stormx]

Originally posted by Half-Handed
I think Ghost and the instrumentals are more like filler

Ghost and the following instrumental are my favourite tracks >_<

[atrocities]

Often I feel like King of Carrot Flowers Part 2 is filler. I'd prefer the hum on the end to launch straight into Up and Over.

[Spoonsharpwit]

Originally posted by atrocities
Often I feel like King of Carrot Flowers Part 2 is filler. I'd prefer the hum on the end to launch straight into Up and Over.

Yeah, I've always thought KoCF pt. 2 was totally filler. 3, too, doesn't seem all that thoughtful. Jeff even admits he didn't write words for part of it.
Everything else, though, seems, to me, to have a purpose besides just taking up space.

[Stormx]

I actually rather like TKOCF Pt. 2. It is quite a nice intro to Pt. 3

[tomatoesandradiowires]

"what should I play next?"
"Jesus christ!"
"...but that doesn't go anywhere."


"still. it's nice to sing a song about jesus."

And so, TKOCF pt. 2 earns its keep.